Exorcism Lite -- Spur Suppressed on 17 meter Transmitter -- Split TX/RX Station On The Air

I spent most of January in the tropics, away from my workbench.  This seems to have had a good effect on my 17 meter split TX/RX project.  As I was leaving, heading south,  I was thinking about several difficult options to deal with my spur problem (see previous blog posts). I thought about turning the transmitter into a transceiver by building a receiver board.   I thought about putting San Jian frequency counters on both the transmitter and the receiver, then doing a visual numerical "netting" by just putting the two devices on the same frequency (I actually ordered 3 San Jian counters).   The counter option was even more complicated than it at first seemed -- I would have to build a converter to shift the RX VFO frequency up.  VK2EMU suggested a tube type "Magic Eye" (interesting idea, but also complicated).   This was getting out of hand. 

When I got back home, I took a new look at the problem.   I decided to take one more shot at suppressing the 8th harmonic of the carrier oscillator.  I had already built a new oscillator and buffer using the circuit from Farhan's BITX20.  And I had put it in a metal box.  Now I decided to do three things: 

1) Tighten up the low pass filter at the output of the buffer by moving the cutoff frequency lower (to around 7 MHz) thereby getting a bit more suppression at 41 MHz

2) Try putting a series LC shunt circuit tuned to 41 MHz  at the output of the carrier oscillator (between the oscillator and the buffer). 

3)  Reduce the voltage to the oscillator/buffer.  I have this on a pot, so I can adjust it down to the point where the remnant of the harmonic is no longer audible, while keeping the main carrier osc signal sufficiently strong. 

It seemed to work.  I could now hear the desired frequency for spotting, without the confusing tone from the spur.  

Why had I been able to do this back in 2002 in the Azores using a simple trimmer cap to ground?  My guess is that I was using my Drake 2-B as the receiver.  The trimmer cap to ground may have reduced harmonic output.  And I was probably cranking back the RF gain on the 2-B to the point where I could hear the desired signal but not the remnants of the spur.  I have no RF gain control on the Barebones Barbados receiver that I am using in this project. 

So, what's the lesson from all this?  Well, if you are faced with a serious technical problem, and you find yourself considering complicated and difficult solutions,  go to the Dominican Republic for about a month (especially if it is January or February), and then take another look at the problem when you return.  If you are unable to travel this far or for this long,  taking a walk or taking a weekend break from a troublesome problem will likely have a similar mind-clearing effect. 

The video above shows part of a February 1, 2022 QSO with Gar WA5FWC using the split TX/RX 17 meter rig.  Gar is an amazing long-time SSB homebrewer who got his start with phasing rigs back in the day.